Tuesday, September 24, 2019

Oakbrook Townhouses Board Meeting Minutes September 9 2019



Minutes of Board of Directors Meeting
September 9, 2019
Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc.
c/o Northwest Properties Agency, Inc.
9527 Bridgeport Way SW
Lakewood, WA 96499

The regular meeting of the Board of Directors of Oakbrook Townhouses (OT) was held September 9, 2019 at the home of Dave Hamann, 7533 Zircon Drive SW, Lakewood, WA.

A quorum being present, Board President Ken Karch called the meeting to order at 7:06 PM.

Board members present were Al Glamba, Dave Hamann, Ken Karch, Steve Rinnan, and Mike Tierney.  Also attending were members Kathy Johnson, Lew and Pam Mildon, and Cathie Reid, and guests Mike Englund and Steven Thompson.  Also attending were Chris Morris and Michelle Selberg from Northwest Properties.

Karch reported that Jim Pearcy had been in the hospital recently, and his Treasurer duties have been carried out by Mike McDonald.  Karch reported that Carol Rehnberg had resigned as a result of selling her unit.  Hamann moved and Tierney seconded to appoint Lew Mildon to fill the expired term ending in January, 2022.  The motion passed.

Karch introduced Mike Englund, the Board’s previous insurance broker, who had served us for a number of years prior to the current engagement with Bell-Anderson.  Karch indicated that Englund is once again available should the Board so choose.

Minutes

Tierney moved and Hamann seconded to approve the August 12, 2019 Board meeting minutes as submitted.  The motion passed.

Treasurer’s Report

In Treasurer Pearcy’s absence, Hamann provided a summary of the budget and expeditures thru August 31, 2019 and directed the Board’s attention to the Financial report submitted by NWP. 

Following discussion of insurance, driveway cost, and our contractor’s invoice, the Board accepted the Treasurer’s report.

The Board authorized McDonald to work with NWP to move necessary funds to advance our ability to reserve insurance payments to allow full payment when due.  

Karch reminded the Board that our first look at a budget for 2020 should be available at the October Board meeting.

Old and New Business

Karch reported that the rear drainage system videoing of Building 7 thru 12 is complete and we are awaiting the maps and proposal for repair.  All mapping and repair work has been completed on Buildings 1 thru 6.

Selberg reported that proposals have been requested for re-guttering of Building 12 and for venting and scupper repair/replacement at one or more locations.  Selberg will invite the CRS contractor to the next meeting.

Karch reported that the Board is awaiting a third proposal for erosion repair at 7513.

Karch reported the Board policy on the rear and common areas was sent to all members with the August minutes.

Karch reported an attorney has been engaged to deal with non-compliance and other issues. Several members reported additional issues and frustration related to non-compliance at 7509 Zircon.

Karch reported that the Board had approved the driveway replacement bids from Concrete Impressions, the low bidder on each of them, at 7433, 7503, and 7717 Zircon, in the amounts of $4,064, $4,912, and $6,928 respectively, plus tax, as recommended by the task force which investigated all driveways, and NWP has notified the contractor to proceed.

Karch reported he had approved a proposal from Critter Control in the amount of $1,367 to correct bat control issues at 7627 Zircon, as reported in the previous meeting. The Board asked NWP to request our contractor to undertake, and report on, a scan of the entire development for bat and similar issues.

Karch reported the final decision of the hearing officer on the Ruby PDD project, has been issued, and copies are available.  He raised the issue of the continued availability of public use of the open space at the west end of the development.

The Board considered the proposal for repair of the garage resulting from an auto accident at 7511 Zircon.  Conditions for approval had been previously sent to the owner, who reported that the proposal would meet those conditions.  On this basis the Board approved the proposal contingent upon compliance with those conditions, with Mildon abstaining.

Karch reported on the construction of five cluster mailboxes, and proposed a switch to the new boxes on October 1, 2019.  The Board discussed the method for providing keys to the owners, and approved a Notice to Members, and a Certification of Receipt.  The Board also asked that the legal issue with the sixth cluster box, serving Buildings 3 and 4, be addressed with the attorney as soon as possible.  Hamann offered to distribute keys, but indicated members who have not received their keys by September 16 must contact NWP to secure them.

Karch reported on an analysis of water use, showing a slight reduction in summer water use, and a slight increase in winter water use.  Water billings have slightly declined for the past three years.

Karch presented a proposal for repair of interior damage due to a roof leak at 7515 Zircon.  Following discussion, the Board decided to seek one or more additional bids.

The Board had a discussion on the capacity of electrical breaker boxes for individual units, urged members to be aware that some breaker boxes may not be capable of handling new electrical loads, and suggested members check with an electrical contractor to determine breaker box capabilities.

The Board went into executive session at 9:28 pm to discuss legal issues regarding compliance issues at 7509 Zircon, the cluster mailbox issue at 7631 Zircon, recording of the CC&Rs/Bylaws, and other legal matters, and returned to regular session at 9:45 pm.  No actions were taken during the executive session, and no actions taken in regular session arising from discussion in the executive session.

Next Meeting

The next regular Board meeting will be held October 14, 2019 at the home of Mike Tierney, 7409 Zircon Drive SW, at 7:00 PM.

It was moved and seconded to adjourn the meeting.  The motion passed and the meeting was adjourned at 9:46 PM.

Respectfully submitted,


_____________________________
Ken Karch, PE, Board President


Oakbrook Townhouses Board Meeting Minutes August 12 2019



Minutes of Board of Directors Meeting
August 12, 2019
Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc.
c/o Northwest Properties Agency, Inc.
9527 Bridgeport Way SW
Lakewood, WA 96499

The regular meeting of the Board of Directors of Oakbrook Townhouses (OT) was held August 12, 2019 at the home of Ken Karch, 7419 Zircon Drive SW, Lakewood, WA.

A quorum being present, Board President Ken Karch called the meeting to order at 7:04 PM.

Board members present were Al Glamba, Dave Hamann, Ken Karch, Mike McDonald, Steve Rinnan, and Mike Tierney.  Also attending were members Kathy Johnson, Tim Lancaster (by POA), Lew and Pam Mildon, Darrell Richards, and Dennis Shuler.  Also attending were Chris Morris and Michelle Selberg from Northwest Properties.

Shuler and McDonald described an incomplete issue regarding the re-connection of vents and adjustment of scuppers following the roof repair on Building 7.  NWP was asked to contact CRS and the Board’s contractor to assess the situation and provide a solution. 

Minutes

Hamann moved and McDonald seconded to approve the July 8, 2019 Board meeting minutes as submitted.  The motion passed.

Treasurer’s Report

In Treasurer Pearcy’s absence, Karch directed the Board’s attention to the Financial report submitted by NWP. 

Old and New Business

Following discussion of the request by the owner at 7631 for approval of new windows, Hamann moved and Tierney seconded to approve the request.  The motion passed.

The Board considered the status of the slope stability study at 7513 Zircon.  An assessment letter from Beyler Engineers was received, and Karch provided a chronology of activities since 1978 on the matter.  Following discussion, McDonald moved and Tierney seconded to ask NWP to secure bids from several companies listed by Beyler.  The motion carried.

The Board considered the need to secure driveway replacement bids for three driveways identified by the Board’s task force as most critical at 7433, 7503, and  7717 Zircon.  Following discussion, McDonald moved and Hamann seconded to ask NWP to seek additional driveway bids by close of business August 26 and authorized an email vote.  The motion passed.

Karch reported that garage repair bids for auto accident damage at 7511 Zircon have not yet been received by the owner, so there is no action to be taken.

Karch reported that the legal service agreement has been received and in being slightly modified.  Following discussion, Hamann moved and Rinnan seconded to approve the proposal and authorize the President to sign.  The motion passed.

Karch reported that Drain Pro has mapped and completed repair work on the rear drainage systems of Buildings 1 through 6; and has completed mapping of Buildings 7 through 12.  We are awaiting the results of the mapping of Buildings 7 through 12 and an assessment of needed repairs to the rear drainage systems.

The Board considered an updated version of the verbal report by the committee of Glamba, McDonald, and Tierney at the July Board meeting on their recommendations for clarification of the responsibilities in the rear common area.  Following discussion, Glamba moved and Tierney seconded to approve the revised policy on the rear and side common areas and authorized its distribution to the membership. The motion passed.

Karch reported that Oakbrook Townhouses does not have a written fines policy for CC&R and Bylaws violations.  Recent events have pointed toward the need to have one, and our attorney has recommended we adopt one.  A draft policy was developed, using another HOA’s policy as a model.  Following discussion, the Board asked that additional examples be secured for further discussion.

McDonald and Rinnan reported there seems to have been no progress made by our contractor on correcting the obscuring vegetation.  McDonald will meet with NWP on the matter.

Karch reported that the Mailbox Guy has completed installation of 5 slabs on which will be mounted cluster mailboxes.  Members are reminded that one mailbox (serving Buildings 3 and 4) is being held in abeyance pending possible legal action by an owner in Building 4).  Discussion with our attorney is expected to result in an opinion on the matter, and the association is proceeding with the remaining cluster mailboxes. 

Glamba and Tierney reported on the recent hearing on the 16-unit Planned Development District (PDD) proposal to be built in the area between Ruby Drive and Zircon Drive formerly occupied by the swimming pool and tennis courts.  The 4th Addition has indicated it will not challenge the current proposal, and the PDD will adopt its own set of governing documents.

Karch distributed copies of the most recent property assessment update, showing 1) the total assessed valuation of individual Oakbrook Townhouses properties reached a peak in 2009 at about $13.4 million, then dropped each year from 2009 through 2014 to about $8.9 million for 2014. During the 2015 thru 2020 period the assessed value rose again to just about $15.7 million, including a $1.3 million increase between 2019 and 2020; 2) the mean assessed value for all 65 Oakbrook Townhouses properties rose from about  $221,000 to about $241,000 from 2019 to 2020, about a 9.2% increase, following an 6.6% increase the previous year; 3) the last 8 sales (2017 thru 2019 to date) have averaged 21 percent above the assessed value at the time of the sale; and 4) the average length of Oakbrook Townhouses unit ownership is 11.3 years, with 5 members who have owned their units for 25 years or more.  All data is publicly available data from the County Assessor’s web site.

Karch announced the Board would go into closed session at 9:01 PM to discuss legal issues raised at the last meeting.

Karch reconvened the Board in open session at 9:32 PM.  There were no actions taken in the closed session and none taken on the matters discussed in the closed session once returning to open session.

Next Meeting

The next regular Board meeting will be held September 9, 2019 at the home of Dave Hamann, 7533 Zircon Drive SW, at 7:00 PM.

It was moved and seconded to adjourn the meeting.  The motion passed and the meeting was adjourned at 9:35 PM.

Respectfully submitted,


_____________________________
Ken Karch, PE, Board President