Tuesday, October 22, 2024

Oakbrook Townhouses Board Meeting Minutes - October 9 2023

 

Minutes of Board of Directors Meeting

October 9, 2023

Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc.

c/o Willow Properties

9527 Bridgeport Way SW

Lakewood, WA 96499

 The regular meeting of the Board of Directors of Oakbrook Townhouses (OT) was held October 9, 2023 at 7705 Zircon Drive SW, Lakewood, WA 98498.

 A quorum being present Board President Al Glamba called the meeting to order at 6:04 PM.

 Board members present were Nancy Dilworth, Al Glamba, Jim Allsopp and Ken Karch (by phone). 

 Approval of Minutes

 Glamba requested approval of the Board meeting minutes of August 14, 2023 and September 11, 2023.

 Dilworth moved and Allsopp seconded approval of the Board meeting minutes of August 14, 2023. The motion passed.

 Allsopp moved and Dilworth seconded approval of the Board meeting minutes of September 11, 2023. The motion passed.

 Treasurer’s Report

 Treasurer Dilworth presented financial and budget information, as of September 30, 2023.

 Checking Account                           $     10,131.11

Reserve Account                             $   194,547.96

Insurance Deductible Account     $       5,042.32

Capital Improvement Account       $       9,728.79

Insurance Holding                           $     24,000.00

 She also listed expenditures during September. She reported that both Karch and she had estimated Operating Account EOY (end-of-year) balances resulting in projections between about $8,000 and $15,000, following all expected receipts and disbursements.

The Board discussed potential for bankruptcies and correction of arrearages, and the move to the accrual method of accounting from the previous cash method.

 2024 Budget

 Dilworth indicated she is proposing, for first reading of the 2024 proposed budget, and in accordance with previous Board discussions, a dues increase to $425 (from $375 currently), or a  special assessment of approximately $50 for one year, both of which would cover an expected shortfall of about $38,000 for 2024.  The Board discussed the reasons for the projected shortfall from 1) a 13.7% increase in insurance premiums; 2) uncertainty regarding 2024 legal expenses; 3) a need to rebuild the Special Projects account and make additional contributions to the Reserve account to meet Reserve Study recommendations; and 4) a need to undertake unexpected projects, including rear deck, driveway, and garage roof replacements.

 The Board discussed the advisability of alternative disposal approaches for materials collected during roof and gutter cleaning; a Board-requested study of the condition of all rear decks by our General Maintenance contractor (to be completed by December 1, 2023); and chimney repair & maintenance.

 Glamba distributed copies of a comparison prepared by Karch of four normalized financial indices for the period 2005 thru 2023: the US Inflation Rate (a 56% increase); the Social Security Adjustment rate (a 56% increase); the Pierce County Assessor’s mean increase for all Oakbrook Townhouses properties (a 144% increase); and total Oakbrook Townhouses dues and assessments (a 20% increase, all over the 18 year period.

 Karch recommended establishment of a work plan for our General Repair & Maintenance contractor, without implying that he is an employee.

 Following further discussion Allsopp moved and Dilworth seconded to approve the Treasurer’s report for October 9, 2023.  The motion passed.

 Heritage Restoration Lawsuit

 Glamba stated this topic would be deferred to later in the agenda.

 Update on 2021 Audit Report

 Glamba reported he sent an engagement letter to Newman CPA, and that Willow Properties was sending required information to the company. We have heard nothing since. Glamba will contact Willow Properties to clarify progress.

 Update on Decision on Wooden Steps and Gravel at 7631 Zircon

 Glamba indicated he had no further information on actions taken since the last Board meeting on this issue.

 Update on Repairs of Exposed Piling at 7631 Zircon

Glamba indicated he had no further information on actions taken since the last Board meeting on this issue.

 Update on Repair/Replacement of Rear Deck and Shingles at 7411 Zircon. 

 Glamba reported the work on these items is complete and has been paid. He asked for Board ratification of the payment to PDQ in the amount of $5,100. Following discussion, Dilworth moved and Allsopp seconded to ratify the payment of $5,100 to PDQ. The motion passed.

 Use of Email Transmission of Draft Monthly Meeting Minutes

 Karch requested that this issue be deferred to the next meeting.

 Goal Assessment

 Glamba distributed the 2022-2023 Goals Assessment data received to date by Karch, along with a proposed set of goals for 2024. The material was reviewed, but no action was taken.

 Risk Associated with Electrical Panels Manufactured by Federal Pacific Electric Company and/or Federal Pioneer LTD

 Glamba and Karch described learnings they had received regarding risks posed by electrical panels manufactured by Federal Pacific Electric Company and/or Federal Pioneer LTD.  The issue surfaced as a result of electrical work requested by Karch, and is widely reported online.  It was also addressed in a walk-through by Glamba with Liberty Mutual as a potential insurance issue. Karch has subsequently replaced his Federal Pacific panel, but it appears that the same panels were installed in the 1970-1972 time frame in a number of Oakbrook Townhouses properties. Plans are underway for further assessments.

 Update on Driveways at 7417 & 7533 Zircon

 Glamba reported that the Goals adopted for 2022-2023 included driveway repair/replacement at 7417 and 7533 Zircon, both of which have been deferred pending a budget review.

 Painting of Garage Door at 7409 Zircon

 Glamba reported the repainting of the garage door at 7409 Zircon and repair of loose tile has been completed.

 Ivy Removal Behind the Units

 Glamba reported that there is nothing further to report on this issue.

 Update on Gutter Overflow at 7419 Zircon

 Karch reported that work on the upper gutter several weeks ago to prevent streaming of water onto the sunroom roof was unsuccessful, as evidenced during the recent storm (the first since the work was done). A request for correction has been submitted to Willow Properties.

 Update on Receipt of Property Management Proposals

 Glamba reported he has received two alternative property management proposals, but none so far from Willow Properties, despite being requested.  He has had one interview.

 Update on Timely Payments of Insurance Premiums

 Glamba reported we have received another Notice of Cancellation from Liberty Mutual.  The Board discussed in detail the reasons for this, including steps Willow Properties could have taken to prevent its recurrence.

 Update on Reserve Account Balances

 Karch reported on his assessment of EOY Reserve Account balances from 2011 thru August, 2023.  Analysis showed a steady annual contribution to both the Reserve Account and the Special Projects Account from 2013 thru 2018 and a drop off since.  The Reserve Account has been holding steady since 2019, oscillating around $180,000, but the Special Projects Account has been almost totally depleted to about $7,000 now (from about $240,000 in 2018).  The Board made a conscious decision to use much of the Special Projects Account funding for a variety of projects in 2019, largely roofing and gutters, thereby putting off another round of replacements by many years.

 Executive Session on Heritage Restoration

 It was moved, seconded, and approved to adjourn to Executive Session. Following Board discussion, during which no Board actions were taken, it was moved, seconded, and approved to return to general session.

 Invoice from McFerran Law

 Glamba requested approval to pay an invoice from McFerran Law in the amount of $731.35 for legal services through September 25, 2023.  Following discussion, Dilworth moved and Allsopp seconded to pay the invoice from McFerran Law in the amount of $731.35. The motion passed.

 Next Board Meeting

 Glamba announced the next Board meeting will be held on November 13, 2023 at 7425 Zircon at 4:00 PM.

 Adjournment

 It was moved and seconded to adjourn the meeting. The motion passed.  The meeting was adjourned at 8:20 PM.

 Respectfully submitted,

 

 

Al Glamba, President

Oakbrook Townhouses Board Meeting Minutes September 11 2023

                                         Minutes of Board of Directors Meeting

September 11, 2023

Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc.

c/o Willow Properties

9527 Bridgeport Way SW

Lakewood, WA 96499

 The regular meeting of the Board of Directors of Oakbrook Townhouses (OT) was held September 11, 2023 at 7427 Zircon Drive SW, Lakewood, WA 98498.

 A quorum being present Board President Al Glamba called the meeting to order at 6:00 PM.

 Board members present were Nancy Dilworth, Al Glamba, Doug Martin and Ken Karch (by phone). Also attending was guest Mike McDonald. 

 Treasurer’s Report

 Treasurer Dilworth presented financial and budget information, as of August 31, 2023.

 Checking Account                           $       9,522.96

Reserve Account                             $   192,546.33

Insurance Deductible Account     $       5,042.32

Capital Improvement Account       $       7,728.73

Insurance Holding                           $     20,000.00

 She also listed expenditures during August.

 Dilworth presented some early suggestions for budget items for 2024, suggesting a shortfall in 2024 of about $38,000. Former Treasurer McDonald explained the manner in which the Board has handled the insurance payments in the past few years, and suggested the shortfall could be managed by 1) a monthly charge increase of about $50, 2) a special assessment of about $52 per month for one year, or 3) elimination of our earthquake insurance and cable TV.

 Following extensive discussion Martin moved and Karch seconded to approve the Treasurer’s report for September 11, 2023.  The motion passed.

 Heritage Restoration Lawsuit

 Glamba stated this topic would be deferred to later in the agenda.

Update on 2021 Audit Report

 Glamba reported he sent an engagement letter to Newman CPA, and that Willow Properties was sending required information to the company. Cost for the 2021 Audit, which is required by the RCWs and our CC&Rs, is expected to be $2,500. 

 Update on Decision on Wooden Steps and Gravel at 7631 Zircon

 Glamba briefed the Board on actions taken since the last Board meeting on this issue. The unit owner has not responded to our August 28, 2023 letter indicating the work is the unit owner’s responsibility and directing our General Maintenance contractor to repair the problem and Willow Properties to bill the unit owner, with any unpaid amount owing to be added to the assessment due by the unit owner.

 Update on Decision on Removal of Fir and Cedar Trees at 7631 Zircon

 Glamba briefed the Board on actions taken since the last Board meeting on this issue, having sent a letter on August 29, 2023 reiterating the provisions of our previous notification, stating that the Association relies on the expertise of certified expert in the field, and indicating that the subject trees are on a Spring, 2024 watch list.

 Update on Repair of Exposed Piling at 7631

 Glamba reported a work order has been submitted to PDQ Contractors to repair the exposed piling at 7631 Zircon, at the expense of the Association.

 Update on Repair/Replacement of Rear Deck and Shingles at 7411 Zircon. 

 Glamba reported the work on these items is scheduled to begin this week by PDQ Contractors.

 Use of Email Transmission of Draft Monthly Meeting Minutes

 Karch described the benefits and problems associated with the transition from USPS mailed documents to the membership to emailed copies (more than just minutes), and urged caution in its implementation.  Dilworth reported there is a tab for “Minutes” on the Web Portal, set up by Willow Properties, but that it has not yet been populated.

 Update on Driveways at 7417 & 7533 Zircon

 Glamba reported that the Goals adopted for 2022-2023 included driveway repair/replacement at 7417 and 7533 Zircon, both of which have been deferred pending a budget review.

 Goal Assessment

 Karch reported on the 2022-2023 Goals Assessment.  The Board agreed to defer the matter to the next Board meeting.

 Miscellaneous Items

 Glamba reported on repair of Comcast lines; Liberty Mutual’s suggestion that we do a thermographic survey, fire extinguishers, fireplace inspections, chimney cleanings, winterization policies; and a proposal to change the Board meeting time.

 Discussion of  Potentially Unsafe Electrical Panels

 Karch reported that an electrical contractor engaged by himself had found an electrical panel produced by Federal Pacific which would not permit them to do other electrical work in his unit without first replacing that panel. Karch authorized the work to be done.  These Federal Pacific panels were widely used during the period of construction of Oakbrook Townhouses (1969-1972). Glamba described the details of the Federal Pacific potential problem, and reiterated that our insurance company had suggested that we undertake some action on this matter. Glamba recommended that we notify all unit owners of the issue and urge them to check their own panels.

 Landscaping of Area at 7419 Zircon

 Dilworth and Karch described the destruction of landscaping between 7417 and 7419 Zircon resulting from the modification of the electrical panel at 7419 Zircon.  Karch moved and Dilworth seconded that PDQ be authorized to correct the extensive dry rot and paint the external paneling and lay down bark mulch. The motion passed.

 Painting of Garage Door at 7409 Zircon

 Glamba reported a work order to PDQ Contractors has been issued for the repainting of the garage door at 7409 Zircon,

 Ivy Removal Behind the Units

 Dilworth moved and Martin seconded to request Willow Properties to obtain a proposal to remove ivy growing on trees to the rear of Oakbrook Townhouses units. The motion passed.

 Executive Session on Heritage Restoration

 It was moved, seconded, and approved to adjourn to Executive Session. Following Board discussion, during which no Board actions were taken, it was moved, seconded, and approved to return to general session.

 Property Management Proposals

 Glamba described the process for securing and evaluating proposals from alternative property management companies.  We have received one such proposal and are expecting another in time for a recommendation to the Board at its October meeting.

 Invoice from McFerran Law

 Glamba requested approval to pay an invoice from McFerran Law in the amount of $525.00 for legal services through August 25, 2023.  The motion passed.

 Next Board Meeting

 Glamba announced the next Board meeting will be held on October 9, 2023 at 7705 Zircon at 6:00 PM.

 Adjournment

 It was moved and seconded to adjourn the meeting. The motion passed.  The meeting was adjourned at 8:03 PM.

 Respectfully submitted,

  

Al Glamba, President

Oakbrook Townhouses Board Meeting Minutes August 14 2023

 

Minutes of Board of Directors Meeting

August 14, 2023

Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc.

c/o Willow Properties

9527 Bridgeport Way SW

Lakewood, WA 96499

 The regular meeting of the Board of Directors of Oakbrook Townhouses (OT) was held August 14, 2023 at 7535 Zircon Drive SW, Lakewood, WA 98498.

 A quorum being present Board President Al Glamba called the meeting to order at 6:06 PM.

 Board members present were Al Glamba, Ken Karch, Mike McDonald and Jim Allsopp via phone.  Also attending were member Dennis Shuler and Rice Insurance’s Mike Englund. 

 Member Comments

 Shuler addressed the Board on responsibility for repair of flow restrictors if they lie within the sheetrock.  He suggested members check their insurance coverage.

 Insurance Proposal

 Englund reported on insurance provisions.  Liberty Mutual (our agent) had insisted on an inspection of the property, and came back with a very complementary assessment.

He shared a synopsis of our coverage and expected provisions for 2024. He indicated our coverage has gone up about 8% to keep up with inflation, and that Liberty Mutual is requiring the Property deductible be increased from $5,000 to $10,000. The Board had an extended discussion about thermographic surveys, fire extinguishers, chimney cleaning, and circuit breaker panels, and agreed that a notice be sent to the membership outlining the insurance company and Board expectations. The premium for General Liability insurance will go up to $53,674 from $47,419.

 Englund presented the proposal for Earthquake Insurance, and the Board had a lengthy discussion about it.  The Earthquake insurance premium will increase to $21,387 from $18,600.

 McDonald moved that the Board accept the proposal form earthquake insurance from Palomar for the period August 23, 2023 to August 23, 2024 in the amount of $21,387.  The motion passed.

 Karch moved and Allsopp seconded to accept the General Liability insurance proposal from Liberty Mutual in the amount of $53,674, including a change in the deductible to $10,000.  The motion passed with McDonald voting Nay.

 McDonald moved and Allsopp seconded to pay the full Earthquake Insurance premium by August 23 in the amount of $21,387.  The motion passed.

 Approval of Minutes

 Glamba requested approval of the Board meeting minutes of June 12, 2023 and July 10, 2023.

 Karch moved and McDonald seconded approval of the Board meeting minutes of June 12, 2023. The motion passed.

 McDonald moved and Allsopp seconded to approve the Board meeting minutes of July 10, 2023. The motion passed.

 Treasurer’s Report

 McDonald referenced the financials for the past month. He reported the following in our various accounts:

 Checking Account                           $     14,865.86

Reserve Account                             $   190,544.71

Insurance Deductible Account     $       5,042.32

Capital Improvement Account       $       5,728.68

Insurance Holding                           $     40,000.00

 He also listed all expenditures during July.

 McDonald moved and Karch seconded that the Board approve an additional transfer of $4,000 in to the Insurance Holding account. The motion passed.

 Enforcement Regarding Monthly Charge-Delinquent Unit Owners

 McDonald recommended that the Board send a letter to all delinquent unit owners to bring their accounts up to date, or provide a plan to do so, or face the enforcement provisions of the CC&Rs.

 Following discussion, McDonald moved and Allsopp seconded that the association send a letter to the four most monthly charge-delinquent unit owners indicating that if the delinquency is not corrected, or a plan submitted to do so, by October 1, the Association will exercise its authority under the CC&Rs to cut off cable service to those unit owners. The motion passed.

 Karch moved and Allsopp seconded to accept the Treasurer’s report.  The motion passed.

 Heritage Restoration Litigation

Glamba indicated this topic would be deferred to a closed session later in the agenda.

 Audit Report

 Glamba reported he had signed the engagement letter to Newman CPA for $2,800, and transmitted it to them, and that the previous auditor had been terminated. Karch asked about the return of materials in the hands of the previous auditor. Glamba said we should expect the audit report for 2021 within 4 to 6 weeks, and will verify with Willow Properties that the materials needed by Newman to complete that audit report have been provided.

 Certification of Backflow Prevention

 Glamba reported the question of the cost of the inspection and certification of the backflow prevention devices is complete.

 Payment for Mailbox Replacement

 Glamba reported the insurance check in payment for the most recent mailbox destruction, in the amount of $3,080 has been received.

 Ratification of Payment for Rear Deck Repair

 Glamba reported the repair of the rear deck at 7611 Zircon is complete, that he had authorized payment in the amount of $1,069.18, and that he asked for Board ratification of said payment.  McDonald moved and Karch seconded that the Board ratify the payment approved by Glamba.  The motion passed.

 Update on Chambers Creek Trail Construction

 Glamba reported the request for extension of time for a permit for certain work on the Chambers Creek Trail has been granted for 1 year and 84 days, commencing on September 11, 2023.

 Reconsideration for Decision on Wooden Steps and Gravel at 7631 Zircon

 Glamba briefed the Board on actions taken since the last Board meeting on this issue. The unit owner has not responded to our previous letter indicating the work is the unit owner’s responsibility and proposed that the Association engage our General Maintenance contractor to repair the problem and bill the unit owner.  Following discussion Allsopp moved to notify the unit owner that the Association will engage our General Maintenance contractor to repair the problem and bill the unit owner, with any unpaid amount owing to be added to the assessment due by the unit owner.  Karch seconded, and the motion passed.

 Reconsideration of Decision on Removal of Fir and Cedar Trees at 7631 Zircon

 Glamba briefed the Board on actions taken since the last Board meeting on this issue, and proposed a letter be sent reiterating the provisions of our previous notification, providing that the Association relies on the expertise of certified expert in the field. 

McDonald moved and Allsopp seconded that the President draft and send such a letter.  The motion passed.

 Repair and Replacement of Rear Decks at 7411, 7613, and 7619

 Glamba reported on three requests for, and his inspection of, rear deck repair/replacements at 7411, 7613, and 7619 Zircon. He reported that the 7411 deck is in urgent need of repair/replacement and that our contractor has indicated the estimated cost is $9,350 including tax, and has requested $4,250 down to secure needed materials. Glamba reported the other two rear decks can be deferred until next year. Following discussion McDonald moved and Allsopp seconded to authorize PDQ Construction to repair/replace the rear deck at 7411 Zircon and advance $4250 for materials. The motion passed.  McDonald moved and Allsopp seconded to have Edwin evaluate all rear decks by December 1 based on criteria provided by the Board. The motion passed.

 Use of Email Transmission of Draft Monthly Meeting Minutes

 Karch described the benefits and problems associated with the transition from USPS mailed documents to the membership to emailed copies, and urged caution in its implementation.  For example, the association would save considerable expense in doing so, and it would provide a paper trail, but members should have to agree in writing to have such notification in lieu of mailed notification.

 Proposed Election of Nancy Dilworth to the Board

 Glamba reported member Nancy Dilworth has agreed to appointment to the Board.  Following discussion McDonald moved and Allsopp seconded to appoint Nancy Dilworth to the Board to fill the position to be vacated by Mike McDonald. The motion passed.

 Proposed Election of Nancy Dilworth As Treasurer

 Glamba reported member Nancy Dilworth has agreed to be appointed as Treasurer.  Following discussion McDonald moved and Allsopp seconded to appoint Nancy Dilworth as Treasurer effective September 1, 2023. The motion passed.

 Property Management Proposals

 Glamba described efforts to secure proposals from property management contractors, including Willow Properties. One has been received and submitted to all Board members for comment.  Glamba and Karch will secure all Board member comments and negotiate with the makers of any further proposals in order to secure a best and final offer, and bring a recommendation to the Board for action.

Miscellaneous Items

 Glamba reported on the repair of the Comcast line at 7719 Zircon; the Building 12 pest issue; completion of the gutters at 7419 Zircon; the Purcor pest control issue; final payment to PDQ for work at 7801 and 7611 Zircon; notices to secure compliance with the needed 2-foot right-of-way behind the units; removal of bamboo; loose shingles and a leaking faucet at 7411 Zircon; gutter cleaning policy, the desirability of establishing a list of contractors (without endorsement) which could be provided to members seeking help.  The Board took no action on any of these issues.

 Proposal for a Web Portal

 Karch reported that Willow Properties had suggested creation of a web portal on which a variety of information would be assembled.  Karch endorsed the basic idea, but expressed concern over the resources necessary to keep it up to date, and suggested that Board discussion on the matter was warranted.

 Driveway Replacement

 Glamba indicated further driveway replacements, including the two approved by the Board on July 11, 2022 (7417 and 7533 Zircon) had been put on hold pending a review of finances.

 Goals Assessment

 Karch reported he has created a tool for assessing how well the Board has completed work on the goals adopted on July 11, 2022, and will distribute it to Board members shortly.

 2024 Budget

 McDonald reported on his assessment of the proposed 2024 budget.  He reported he expects a shortfall of $35,000 to $40,000, and suggested 3 ways to handle it: 1) a dues increase; 2) a special assessment, and 3) elimination of cable TV and earthquake insurance. He recommended the Board review and decide on a course of action as the proposed budget numbers are presented.

 Executive Session on Heritage Restoration

 It was moved, seconded, and approved to adjourn to Executive Session. Following Board discussion, during which no Board actions were taken, it was moved, seconded, and approved to return to general session.

 Payment to McFerran Law for Services Rendered

 Glamba described work done during July by McFerran Law in the amount of $3,828 and asked for a motion to pay. McDonald moved and Allsopp seconded to pay $3,828 to McFerran Law for service rendered during July.  The motion passed.

 Next Board Meeting

 Glamba announced the next Board meeting will be held on September 11, 2023 at a time and location to be determined.

 Adjournment

 It was moved and seconded to adjourn the meeting. The motion passed.  The meeting was adjourned at 9:08 PM.

 Respectfully submitted,

  

 

Al Glamba, President