Tuesday, October 22, 2024

Oakbrook Townhouses Annual Meeting Minutes January 17 2023

 

DRAFT Annual Meeting Minutes DRAFT

January 17, 2023

Oakbrook Townhouse, Inc.

c/o Willow Properties, Inc.

9527 Bridgeport Way SW

Lakewood, WA 96499

 The Oakbrook Townhouses 2023 Annual Members’ meeting took place January 17, 2023 at the Oakbrook RMG Golf Club, 8102 Zircon Drive SW, Lakewood, WA 98498.

 ATTENDANCE

 Board members attending in person were Al Glamba, Ken Karch, Doug Martin, and Mike McDonald (via phone). Also attending was Carrie Snyder of Willow Properties. Several members also attended.

 QUORUM

 Materials returned were sufficient to constitute a quorum for the Annual Members’ meeting.

 MEETING RULES

 It was moved, seconded and approved that the meeting be generally governed by Roberts’ Rules of Order.

 MEMBER MAILOUT

 The 2023 budget adopted by the Board, the nomination and ballot for Board members, and the draft 2022 Annual Members’ meeting minutes and other materials were sent out in a timely manner to the membership in accordance with the Oakbrook Townhouses CC&Rs and Bylaws.

 BUDGET RATIFICATION

 Members ratified the Board-adopted 2023 budget, providing a continuation of the level of monthly charges at $375.

 2022 ANNUAL MEMBER MEETING MINUTES

 It was moved, seconded, and approved to dispense with the reading of the minutes of the January 18, 2022 Annual Members’ Meeting. It was then moved, seconded, and approved to approve the minutes of the January 18, 2022 Annual Members’ Meeting.

 STATE OF THE ORGANIZATION

 Glamba reported on the election of the following officers, immediately following the 2022 Annual Members’ meeting: Al Glamba, President; Ken Karch, Vice-President, and Mike McDonald, Treasurer.  The position of Secretary remains open.

 Glamba reported that Oakbrook Townhouses has been sued by Heritage Restoration for alleged non-payment of portions of a contracted amount covered by Liberty Mutual, our insurer.  Oakbrook Townhouses has retained an attorney to assist in protecting its interests.

 Glamba reported on the sale during 2022 of Northwest Properties, Inc. by Bill and Pat Price to Willow Properties, Inc., and several issues that had arisen during the transition period to the new ownership

 Glamba reported notification that Oakbrook Townhouses’ registration with the Washington Secretary of State had expired for failure to re-register, but that that problem had been resolved.

 Glamba also reported that our insurance agent had notified Oakbrook Townhouses of a pending cancellation due to non-payment of premiums.  This problem has been resolved.

 Glamba reported that many of our unit owners had been notified that their monthly charges were not current, when, in fact, they were.  This problem is being investigated and is expected to be resolved soon.

 Glamba reported that funds approved by the Board and ratified by the membership in the 2021 and 2022 budgets for contributions to the Reserve funds were not fully deposited.

 Glamba reported Oakbrook Townhouses is still awaiting its audit for 2021, and expects it soon.

 Glamba reported the Board beat back an attempt by the single family development being constructed on the south side of Zircon Drive to utilize the cluster mailboxes recently installed at the expense of the association.

 STATE OF OAKBROOK TOWNHOUSES, INC.

by Al Glamba

After many years of dedicated and distinguished service, Ken Karch stepped down as President of Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc., effective March 31, 2022. However, he agreed to remain as a candidate for Vice President of the Association. Prior to stepping down, Karch organized the election of new officers of the Board, resulting in the election of me, Al Glamba, as President; Ken Karch as Vice President; and Mike McDonald as Treasurer. There were no nominations for the Secretary position, which position is still vacant.

After many months of not having in person monthly meetings or meeting in open vented garages, while practicing social distancing, I scheduled a meeting of the Board on May 9, 2022 in the conference room of Northwest Properties Agency, Inc., where we said goodbye to Pat and Bill Price who had sold their business to Willow Properties, LLC, the current property Manager of Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc.

Shortly after taking over as President of Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc., a series of unexpected events took place in succession. In June 2022, I learned that Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc., was being sued by Heritage Restoration Inc., for alleged damages for nonpayment by Liberty Mutual Insurance Co., our property and liability insurer, for work performed as a result of a fire that occurred at 7617 Zircon Drive SW, prior to termination of that contract for breach of contract. That litigation is still ongoing.

Next, I learned that the registration of Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc., with the Secretary of State's Office in the State of Washington had expired. Fortunately, that situation has been resolved since then.

That was soon followed by learning that Liberty Mutual Insurance Co., provided notice that it was going to terminate our property and liability insurance policy for overdue insurance premiums. Fortunately, that situation too has been resolved, and the Association has paid off the remaining balance on our current insurance policy with Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.

Subsequently, I learned that many of our unit owners were not paying their monthly dues, which situation has not been resolved. The delinquency rate on our monthly dues has ballooned to 22 as of December 31, 2022. That is approximately one-third of our 65 units, and according to Willow Properties, LLC the arrearages total $28,656.00. That is over $28,000 that the Association does not have in its operating account to expend on the needed expenses of the Association. Remember, only the Federal Government is authorized to operate at a deficit!

This event was soon followed by learning that deposits to our capital improvements and reserve accounts were not being made as originally assumed. In addition, we are still waiting for the results of an audit for calendar year 2021, which audit had been requested long ago.

However, with the funds that the Association did have the Association paid off the remaining balance of its insurance policy with Liberty Mutual Insurance Co., as previously stated, paid all of the insurance premiums for the Association's earthquake insurance policy, and paid the legal expenses of of McFerran Law to defend Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc., in its litigation with Heritage Restoration, Inc., regarding the fire damage claim.

In addition, the Board beat back an attempt to appropriate our unused cluster boxes by the U.S. Postal Service for the use of the new property owners of the Oakbrook Planned Development community across the way on Zircon Drive SW, or in the alternative, to install cluster mailboxes on our side of the right of way of Zircon Drive SW for the use of the new property owners across the street.

Further, the Board resolved a dispute with neighbors regarding debris left out on the driveway, sidewalk, and common property of the Association; approved a Fines policy, which had received a legal review; removed a large fir tree, which was partly rotted, and posed an immediate safety hazard to the unit that was closest to the tree had the tree fallen unto that unit or to an adjoining unit; replaced a backflow prevention valve; replaced a rear deck; entered into an agency agreement with the Lakewood Police Department for the removal of trespassers and unauthorized vehicles from the premises; however, the Board is still waiting for clearance to erect the No Trespassing signs in front of the two end units; deadwooded a honey locust tree that had been characterized as a “widow maker”; replaced a number of sprinkler heads that had been run over by careless drivers; took a trek through a significant portion of Chambers Creek Canyon and located two encampments on the south side of that canyon, and then risked life and limb to climb the 300-foot bluff out of the canyon as darkness was approaching; repaired a sewage line that was causing a sewage backup in one of the units and could have impacted other adjoining units; and repaired several water leaks.

There is still an electrical failure of the outside lamp posts of several units for which the Board is awaiting bids to jackhammer through a concrete driveway and to dig a trench underneath that driveway to obtain access to the electrical line that needs to be replaced.

 

TREASURER’S REPORT


Due to difficulties hearing our Treasurer, Glamba presented the Treasurer’s Report.

BUDGET

The Board has determined that a monthly charge increase is not needed for the period 2023 through 2024, and has adopted a 2023 budget which maintains the monthly charges at $375.  It believes that we will be able to maintain the monthly charge at $375 per month per unit through 2024.  The increase of $30 per month approved by the Board and ratified by the membership in 2022 is due to contractor and utility rate increases, fuel and raw material price increases, delays associated with supply chain issues, the need to replenish our reserve and special projects accounts, and the increase in the general inflation rate. 

New Washington State Legislation provides that the Board-approved budget is ratified, unless a majority of members reject it.  In the case of rejection, the most recently approved previous monthly charge (i.e., $375 per month) remains in effect.

Glamba reported the 2023 Oakbrook Townhouses budget is ratified.

RESERVE STUDY

By Al Glamba

After the materials for this year's Annual Meeting were mailed out, the Board received the results of the long overdue on-site Reserve Study. After reviewing the Reserve Study, I want to focus on one portion of that Reserve Study that particularly jumps out at the reader, namely, the replacement of the exterior siding. It appears that the author of the Reserve Study assumed that because the exterior siding of all the buildings was over 50 years old, ipso facto, by virtue of the same fact, extensive portions of the exterior siding needed to be replaced at the same time and then repainted, regardless of whether the siding had failed or needed to be replaced. The author of the Reserve Study did not conduct any water penetration tests, nor did he conduct any intrusive observations to determine whether the exterior siding had any water barrier beneath the siding. He just assumed that it did not, solely from visual observation. In fact, he recommended that the Board contract for a building envelope study of the buildings at Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc., thus verifying the merits of his assumptions. The problem is that the Reserve Study estimated the cost to replace the siding at almost $2,000,000, actually $1.99 million, and then to paint all the buildings at an additional cost of $231,000, which would require a special assessment to cover those costs, and then the Reserve Study front-loaded those costs rather than spread them out.

In the past, when it came to replacing the exterior siding that had dry rot or otherwise needed replacement and subsequently to paint all the buildings, the Board through careful planning and management was able to accomplish those tasks for less than one-third of the estimated amount in the Reserve Study. For example, the 2009 Reserve Study estimated the cost of the exterior building repair/replacement at over $930,000 in calendar year 2015 and an additional $110,000 for painting in calendar year 2016, for a total amount of over one million dollars for calendar years 2015 and 2016. Instead, the Board decided to get a head start on the assessment of the exterior siding by conducting a moisture study of the building exteriors in 2014 to guide the contractor where repair/replacement needed to be performed, and then to carry out the painting project over a three-year period. The moisture study focused on the sides of all of the buildings, which comprised about 75% of the exposed external painted surfaces of all the units and was based upon the wind rose for this geographical area. As a result, the total costs of the exterior siding repair and replacement totaled $297,288, which was 28.6% of the projected Reserve Study costs for those two projects, and as they say past performance is no guarantee of future results, but there appears to be a tendency of the Reserve Study to overstate the estimated costs, and in some cases, as here, to greatly overstate those estimated costs. Perhaps it is because there is no downside to overestimating costs, while there is a downside to underestimating those costs to the Associations. Nevertheless, the new Reserve Study brought to the attention of the Board that repair/replacement of the exterior siding and then painting the buildings is an anticipated cost that the Board will have to plan for and to deal with in the near future.

In addition, the Reserve Study recommended a building envelope study, to include the glass windows and glass sliding doors, even though glass windows and glass sliding doors are a responsibility of the individual unit owners under Article X of the Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions of Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc., which clearly states, “Such exterior maintenance shall not include glass surfaces,” as well as Article VI, Section 3, of the By-Laws, which also states, “Such exterior maintenance shall not include glass surfaces.” Thus, while a Reserve Study is a valuable tool to use for planning purposes by the Board and is required by Section 64.38.065 of the Revised Code of Washington, reasoned careful judgment also needs to be applied in planning for the required maintenance, repair, and replacement of the components identified in the Reserve Study for which the Board has oversight.

There are a limited number of copies of the Reserve Study on the table near the entrance to the doorway. For the rest of those who want a copy of the Reserve Study, you can obtain a copy of the Reserve Study from Willow Properties, LLC, by providing your e-mail addresses, or by picking up a hard copy of the Reserve Study from Willow Properties, LLC at 9527 Bridgeport Way SW, in Lakewood, Washington, at its usual charge of $.15 per page.

RESERVE STUDY ANALYSIS

At Glamba’s request, Karch described the large spreadsheet he developed, containing all the individual numbers from the three past contracted Reserve Studies (2009, 2012, and 2016-17).  He also included the internal assessments we did in 2011 and 2020.  He also added the data from the 2023 contracted study.  Although the spreadsheet is daunting, you may pay attention only to the yellow (highlighted) data if you are only interested in the 2023 data. It covers the period from 2023 through 2052. Copies are available on request.

Karch reported the contracted studies modified the project numbering system in 2012 and again in 2023, so he lumped the original and modified data (for the same projects) together for the whole spreadsheet.  The like items are contained in white and grey bands across the spreadsheet.

In 2020, recognizing the time value of money and the highly variable contractor costs we have experienced in the past three years, he calculated, for the first time, a net present value of all future from all (now 6 studies) costs.  All four contracted studies assumed a 3% inflation rate, and he have used this in the NPV analysis. 

The NPV analysis shows the following NPV of all future costs:

2009 Study                $3,182,592

2011 Update               2,352,908

2012 Study                  2,933,073

2017 Study                  4,008,108

2020 Update               2,298,073

2023 Study                  5,630,050

Note that the updates are considerable lower than the studies.  This is primarily because the Board chose to take advantage of favorable contractor rates, defer less needed work, spread work over 3 or 4 years rather than the single year contemplated in the studies, carry out some of the work with other portions of the budget (post lights, irrigation, tuck pointing), eliminate short term costs (cluster mailboxes), and make use of analyses (such as the moisture study on our siding) to prioritize work that needed to be done. All of these eliminated or deferred costs contemplated in the contracted studies.

 Analysis

 The thing that sticks out is the large jump in the NPV in the 2023 Study.  This is due largely to the “front-loading” of two projects associated with the repair and cleaning of the external walls of the units ($1,990,000 and $231,000 respectively) in 2023.  Front loading causes short term high cost items to have an inordinate effect on NPV…were these items to occur 10 years from now, the effect on NPV would be about 30% less. Furthermore, these are the two items which we carried out in 2011 thru 2014 as part of the last external painting project.  The moisture studies conducted at that time revealed that about 20% of the old wood siding needed replacement (using an industry standard  20% moisture content as a cut-off), which was completed prior to the painting. The moisture study focused on the sides of all buildings, comprising about 75% of the exposed external painted surfaces of all units, and was based on the attached wind rose for this area, from whence cometh the biggest storms.  Note that Oakbrook Townhouses is aligned roughly in a southwest to northeast direction.

 Karch said his own view is that another moisture study needs to be conducted before engaging in a wholesale replacement of all siding at a very large cost.  He recalled that at least one side on one building was replaced by fiber cement siding (7813) and that several others were partially replaced.  The Board had agreed that future siding would be such fiber cement siding.

 Some Board members have indicated that the past painting job has endured much better than expected, and that siding problems seem to be minimal.

 QUESTIONS

 Glamba offered a chance for members to ask questions, which centered around how much longer construction across the street will take, given construction equipment and traffic issues; who owns the property; and what will be the disposition of the open space required to be retained; problems with checks for monthly charges not being cashed; how to make online payments; repair and maintenance on the light poles; and a policy on combustibles.

 BOARD MEMBER NOMINEES

 Glamba explained the process for electing Board members.  The Board consists of between 5 and 9 members, elected for three-year terms. This year the terms of Al Glamba and Mike McDonald are up, both have indicated a willingness to serve another term, and we have a total of up to five positions to fill. Glamba asked for nominations, and reminded the members that anyone nominated must be willing to serve.  It was moved, seconded, and approved to nominate Al Glamba, Mike McDonald, Lew Mildon, Nancy Dilworth, and Paul McFadden. It was moved, seconded and approved to close the elections. Each nominee was given an opportunity to address the members on their interests and qualifications for service.  Glamba announced the vote for Board members as follows: Glamba 20 votes; McDonald 20 votes; Mildon 1; Dilworth 1 vote; and McFadden 1 vote, and declared their election, subject only to an inquiry into the willingness of Dilworth and McFadden to serve.

 MISCELLANEOUS ITEMS

 Glamba brought the membership up to date on a water leak in Building 1 and new No Trespassing signs.

 ADJOURNMENT

 It was moved, seconded, and approved to adjourn the meeting.

 Respectfully submitted,

  

Al Glamba, President

 

Oakbrook Townhouses Board Meeting Minutes May 9 2022

 Minutes of Board of Directors Meeting

May 9, 2022

Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc.

c/o Northwest Properties Agency, Inc.

9527 Bridgeport Way SW

Lakewood, WA 96499

 The regular meeting of the Board of Directors of Oakbrook Townhouses (OT) was held May 9, 2022 at 9527 Bridgeport Way SW, Lakewood, WA 98499.

 A quorum being present Board President Al Glamba called the meeting to order at 7:02 PM.

 Board members present were Rick Boulware, Al Glamba, Ken Karch, Mike McDonald (by phone), Doug Martin, and Steve Rinnan. Also in attendance was Chris Morris from Northwest Properties (NWP)

 Thanks to Karch for Service as President

 Glamba reviewed the progress of the Board during recent years and thanked Karch for his involvement and leadership during that time.

 Minutes

 Boulware moved and Martin seconded to approve September 13, 2021 meeting minutes as submitted. The motion carried

 Financial Report – April 2022

 Morris explained the layout of the Financial Report. She reported on cash on hand, insurance payments, and accounts receivable. Following discussion, it was learned that one of the serious accounts receivables had committed to become current in the next two months, but no response has been received from the other following multiple attempts.  Boulware moved and Karch seconded to ask the Association attorney to communicate with the owner at 7811 Zircon on the need to become current on monthly charges. The motion passed.

 Boulware moved and Martin seconded to approve the financial report.  The motion passed.

 McDonald reported on recent health issues and that he is expecting to return to Oakbrook later this week.  The Board wished him well.

 Status of Insurance Policy

 Karch reported on a conversation with Mike Englund of Rice Insurance that morning. Our premiums come due August 23; amounts paid for the year ending August 23, 2022 are:

Package                    $40,259.00

Business Auto                 254.00.

Umbrella                        2,172.00

Earthquake                16,450.00

                        Total               $59,135.00

 Karch reported that expectations for next year are in the range of a 10-15% increase, and that the recent fire damage event at 7617 Zircon would probably not significantly affect our rate, given our long history of good results.  He reported that there are fewer companies who wish to continue in the HOA insurance market, but that our broker reports that he is confident that at least two are likely to bid, and he will have initial estimates by next month.

 Reserve Study

 Glamba urged Oakbrook Townhouses to contract with Association Reserves for a new 3-year reserve study this year. Following discussion, Glamba and Karch agreed to meet with the company during their site visit.  Glamba will sign the engagement letter.

 Ruby Development

 Glamba reported on the new homes being built on the south side of Zircon Drive and north side of Ruby Drive, the site of the previous swimming pool and tennis courts. Comments were made about the new posted prices, the location of driveways, and traffic.

 Encampment on Chambers Creek

 Glamba reported on a visit to the area of a previous encampment along Chambers Creek slightly downstream from Oakbrook Townhouses.  He reported signs of temporary, but not permanent, activity, and signs from Pierce County warning of unsafe and environmentally sensitive conditions.

 Chambers Creek Trail Update

 Glamba reported on two recently constructed bridges over Chambers Creek and Leach Creek in the vicinity of Kobayashi Park.  These are part of the planned Chambers Creek Trail project, being developed by the Cities of University Place and Lakewood, and Pierce County.

 Rain Gutter Cleaning

 Glamba raised the issue of periodic cleaning of the gutters, including the decision by the Board several years ago to clean them on a quarterly basis.

 Driveway Replacement

 Glamba reported on his review of the condition of driveways in Oakbrook Townhouses.  On motion by Boulware and second by Karch, the Board agreed to review the desirability of additional driveway repair/replacement as part of a broader review of the Board’s goals and priorities at the next meeting.

 Future Board Meeting Locations

 The Board discussed the need to identify future Board meeting locations, including the County library system, the Oakbrook Country Club Condominiums, the Country Club, Zoom Meetings, and members’ homes.  The Board agreed to contact the Country Club for the next meeting.  McDonald offered to hold it if the Country Club was not available.

 Repair at 7511 Roof

 Glamba reported CRS had been contracted to repair damage to the roof at 7511 Zircon resulting from a wind storm, and requested approval to pay the CRS bill in the amount of $764.45. Karch moved and Boulware seconded to approve the invoice. The motion passed.

 Water Leak at 7605 Zircon

 Glamba reported on a complex issue of a water leak at 7605 Zircon. Karch moved and Boulware seconded to authorize the President to move expeditiously to secure needed leak location identification to determine responsibility.

 RV Parked Using Association Electricity

 Glamba reported on an RV parked overnight in the driveway at 7607 Zircon and apparently using association electricity.  A motion was made and seconded to issue a cease and desist order to prohibit use of association power from the street light. The motion passed, with Karch opposed, citing insufficiency.

 Use of Cluster Mailboxes by Ruby Drive Development

 Glamba reported on a request from the US Postal Service to permit homeowners in the new development along Zircon Drive to use a portion of the Oakbrook Townhouses cluster mailboxes or to permit a new cluster mailbox to be installed on Oakbrook Townhouses property. Following discussion, Boulware moved & Karch seconded that NWP respond to the USPS indicating that Oakbrook Townhouses is not interested in permitting non-Oakbrook Townhouse residents to use Oakbrook Townhouses cluster mailboxes, nor to construct, on Oakbrook Townhouses property, additional cluster mailboxes for their use, since there are reasonable alternatives. The motion carried.

 Materials Deposited On Common Area at 7711 Zircon

 Glamba described, and Karch distributed photos, of the deposit of materials in the front, side, and rear of the property at 7711 Zircon.  The Board was reminded of a similar situation several years ago at the same address.  Following discussion, Karch moved and Boulware seconded to ask the health and fire authorities to inspect the site and take appropriate actions as are necessary, and further, that we post a letter to the owner of the violations, demanding corrections within 14 days, or the association will remove and dispose of all such materials and charge the owner for the cost of such removal and disposal.  Furthermore, a posting of the association letter will be delivered in person, if possible, and posted on the door.  The motion passed.

 Member Complaint Regarding Damage to a Sign at 7631

 Glamba reported on a May 4 letter from the owner at 7631 Zircon demanding certain actions in response to alleged damage to a sign placed in the common area.  Following discussion, the Board directed NWP to respond to the letter indicating the letter has been received and will be investigated, and reminding the owner, once again, of the provisions of the CC&Rs regarding signs in the common area.

 Next Board Meeting

 Next Board Meeting is tentatively scheduled for Monday, June 13, 2022 at 7:00 PM, at the Oakbrook Golf & Country Club, or, alternatively, at 7531 Zircon Drive, location to be announced.

 Adjournment

 It was moved and seconded to adjourn the meeting. The motion passed.  The meeting was adjourned at 9:20 PM.

 Respectfully submitted,

  

__________________________

Al Glamba, Preside

Oakbrook Townhouses Board Meeting Minutes December 12 2022

 

Minutes of Board of Directors Meeting

December 12, 2022

Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc.

c/o Willow Properties

9527 Bridgeport Way SW

Lakewood, WA 96499

 

The regular meeting of the Board of Directors of Oakbrook Townhouses (OT) was held December 12, 2022 at 7419 Zircon Drive SW, Lakewood, WA 98498.

 A quorum being present Board President Al Glamba called the meeting to order at 7:02 PM.

 Board members present were Al Glamba, Ken Karch, Doug Martin, Steve Rinnan, and Mike McDonald (by phone).  Also present was Carrie Snyder of Willow Properties.

 Minutes

 McDonald moved and Karch seconded approval of the November 14, 2022 Board meeting minutes as submitted. The motion passed.

 Treasurer’s Report

 McDonald’s presented a summary of the financials for the past month. He reported the following in our various accounts:

 Checking Account                              $     21,204.74

Reserve Account                                $   174,232.78

Insurance Deductible Account           $       5,042.32

Capital Improvement Account            $     20,135.42

Insurance Holding                               $     25,490.00

 and Expenses for the month of $19,566.00.

 Following discussion, McDonald moved and Karch seconded to pay the balance of our insurance bill to Liberty Mutual Insurance.  The motion passed.

 Karch moved and Martin seconded to approve the Treasurer’s Report for November.  The motion passed.

 2023 Budget

 Glamba requested comments on, and final approval of, the proposed 2023 budget. Karch reminded members that the budget had had a first and second reading in the October and November meetings, and provides a continuation of the monthly charges of $375, with no special assessment.  Snyder reminded members that, under state law, the Board approves the budget, and the membership may only reject the budget by a majority vote of members present at the annual meeting.  If members reject the Board approved budget, the budget for the previous year continues until the Board adopts an alternative budget.  Thus, there is no ballot to include in the mail-out materials to the members announcing the annual meeting. Following discussion, Martin moved and Karch seconded approval of the 2023 budget.  The motion passed.

 Contributions to Reserve Accounts

 Glamba reported that some planned contributions to the reserve accounts had not been made during 2021 and 2022.  Following discussion, McDonald moved and Rinnan seconded that the Board move forward starting January 1, 2023 with contributions of $2,000 monthly to each of the reserve accounts (in accordance with the 2023 budget) without backfilling for previous months.  The motion passed, with Martin abstaining.

 Reserve Study

 Glamba reported on a meeting with the contractor and Karch to kick off the 2023 Reserve Study, at which a packet of material was provided.  A set of questions by the contractor was also answered following that meeting.  The report is expected soon.

 Update on 7811 Sewage Backup

 Glamba reported on findings of the contractor engaged to correct this issue.  Work was expected to be completed during the week.

 Update on Water Leaks at 7501 and 7807

 Glamba reported that the water leak at 7501 Zircon had been completed, but that the leak at 7807 remains to be corrected, with a contractor engaged to investigate.

 Update on Placement of No Trespassing Signs

 Glamba reported that the signs have been completed, but that the agent normally responsible for utility locates has changed its policy to now require the applicant to identify its proposed location, following which an approval or rejection will be provided.

 Proposed Policy on Pesticides

 Karch presented proposed wording on a policy on application of pesticides, and asked Board members to review it and be prepared to discuss it at a future meeting.

 Review of Audit Reports

 Karch reported on difficulties acquiring the 2019 audit report and that the 2021 materials have been sent to our auditor, but a report is not yet available.

 Review of Property Mangement Proposal

 Glamba reported first discussions have been held with Willow Properties on its proposed contract for property management, following its acquisition of Northwest Properties earlier this year.  The Board has also secured two additional proposals which are also under review.

 Preparation for Annual Members’ Meeting

 Glamba announced that the 2023 Annual Members’ Meeting is scheduled for January 23, 2023 at the Oakbrook Golf Club starting at 7:00 PM, and that the announcement and related materials will be mailed to the members in the next few days.

 Cancellation of January 9, 2023 Board Meeting

 Glamba asked that the regular January Board meeting be cancelled, and that any business be conducted via email.  Martin moved and Rinnan seconded to cancel the January 9, 2023 Board meeting.  The motion passed.

 Outdoor Lights Failure

 Glamba described an apparent electrical failure to the pole lamps in the area of Buildings 5 and 6, and indicated that an electrician has been engaged to assess and correct the issue.

 Work Order Principles

 Karch passed out and reviewed a document he prepared to memorialize the work order process being followed by the Oakbrook Townhouses management company, and asked the Board to consider it as a possible policy going forward.

 Next Board Meeting

 Glamba announced the next Board meeting will be held immediately following the Annual Members’ Meeting on January 23, 2023

 Executive Session

 Glamba recessed the meeting to go into Executive Session to discuss the current Heritage Restoration lawsuit on fire damage at 7617 Zircon.  During the session, no actions were taken, and the Board then reconvened into open session.

 Adjournment

 It was moved and seconded to adjourn the meeting. The motion passed.  The meeting was adjourned at 8:53 PM.

 Respectfully submitted,

  

 

Al Glamba, President

 

Oakbrook Townhouses Board Meeting Minutes November 14 2022

 

Minutes of Board of Directors Meeting

November 14, 2022

Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc.

c/o Willow Properties

9527 Bridgeport Way SW

Lakewood, WA 96499

 

The regular meeting of the Board of Directors of Oakbrook Townhouses (OT) was held November 14, 2022 at 7705 Zircon Drive SW, Lakewood, WA 98498.

 A quorum being present Board President Al Glamba called the meeting to order at 7:14 PM.

 Board members present were Rick Boulware, Al Glamba, Ken Karch, and Steve Rinnan.

 Minutes

 Boulware moved and Karch seconded approval of the October 10, 2022 Board meeting minutes as submitted. The motion passed.

 Treasurer’s Report

 In McDonald’s absence, Glamba presented a summary of the financials for the past month. He reported the following in our various accounts:

 Checking Account                              $     17,145.41

Reserve Account                                $   181,131.34

Insurance Deductible Account           $       5,042.32

Capital Improvement Account            $     60,143.19

Insurance Holding                               $     26,229.20

 and Expenses for the month of $30,281.61.

 Boulware moved and Rinnan seconded to approve the Treasurer’s Report for October.  The motion passed.

 Glamba initiated discussion regarding late fees for delinquent payments. As members are aware, the Association suspended imposition of late fees pursuant to the Governor’s COVID orders, which have been lifted. Following discussion, Boulware moved and Rinnan seconded to re-impose the imposition of late fees effective December 1, 2022.  The motion passed.

 2023 Budget

 Glamba requested comments on, and second reading of, the proposed 2023 budget.  Following discussion on earthquake insurance, electric and water budgets, contributions to the reserve and capital improvement accounts, status of approval, and annual meeting issues; Boulware moved and Rinnan seconded to approve, on a second reading, the proposed 2023 Budget for Oakbrook Townhouses. The motion passed.  A third and final reading and adoption will occur at the December board meeting, prior to mail out to the membership for ratification at the annual meeting in January. The proposed budget for 2023 does not include a dues increase.

Reserve Study

 Glamba reported on a meeting with the Association Reserves representation in preparation for the 2022 reserve study. Once complete, it will be made available to the membership.

 Water Leak at 7811 Zircon

 Glamba reported that progress has been limited on this issue due to delays in permitting and other issues.  The Board discussed difficulties in ascertaining the source of the problem. 

 Sunroom Painting at 7631 Zircon

 Glamba reported this work has been completed.

 Policy on Herbicide Application

 Glamba reported on the need for a policy on application of herbicides, fungicides, rodenticides, and insecticides.  The Board was cautioned on making any approvals of such applications, since they are all heavily regulated.  The Board felt the need for further review and discussion on this matter and tabled further discussion at the meeting.

 No Trespassing Signage

 Glamba reported that the no trespassing signs have been completed and are ready for installation, and that they are awaiting marking of locations to avoid conflict with utilities.

 Update on Heritage Restoration Lawsuit

 Glamba reported on our attorney retainer fee, setting of a status call date, and receipt of discovery materials.

 Water District Leak Notice

 Glamba reported that the Lakewood Water District had issued notices of running water at 7501 and 7807 Zircon, and that our maintenance contractor had not been able to determine the source from his outside observation.  The Board was apprised of the other possible causes, and requested Willow Properties to contact the owners to identify possible internal leaks.

 Testing of Backflow Prevention

 Glamba reported on recent regulations of the Lakewood Water District for mandatory annual testing of backflow prevention devices.

 Review of Audit Reports

 Karch reviewed results of past audit reports required by Oakbrook Townhouses’ governing documents, and indicated the 2021 audit report materials have been submitted to our auditor.

 Executive Session

 On motion approved by the Board, Glamba called an Executive Session on matters related to the financial condition of the Association, contract issues, and legal matters. No actions were taken in the Executive Session. On motion approved by the Board to return to regular session, Glamba declared the Executive Session at an end and returned the Board to Regular Session.

 Management Contract

 It was moved, seconded, and approved to authorize the President and officers to begin negotiations with Willow Properties for a new management contract, and to keep the Board apprised of the progress of the negotiations.

 Next Board Meeting

 The next Board meeting is scheduled for Monday, December 12, 2022 at 7:00 PM, at 7419 Zircon Drive.

 Adjournment

 It was moved and seconded to adjourn the meeting. The motion passed.  The meeting was adjourned at 9:28 PM.

 Respectfully submitted,

  

 

Al Glamba, President

 

Oakbrook Townhouses Boar Meeting Minutes October 10 2022

 

Minutes of Board of Directors Meeting

October 10, 2022

Oakbrook Townhouses, Inc.

c/o Willow Properties

9527 Bridgeport Way SW

Lakewood, WA 96499

 

The regular meeting of the Board of Directors of Oakbrook Townhouses (OT) was held October 10, 2022 at 7705 Zircon Drive SW, Lakewood, WA 98498.

 A quorum being present Board President Al Glamba called the meeting to order at 7:08 PM.

 Board members present were Rick Boulware, Al Glamba, Ken Karch, and Mike McDonald via telephone.

 Minutes

 McDonald moved and Boulware seconded approval of the September 12, 2022 Board meeting minutes as submitted. The motion passed.

 Treasurer’s Report

 McDonald presented a summary of the financials for the past month. He reported the following in our various accounts:

 Checking Account                              $     7,810.42

Reserve Account                                $ 174,229.94

Insurance Deductible Account           $     5,042.32

Capital Improvement Account            $    53,242.65

 and Expenses for the month of $66,334.85,

 Boulware moved and Karch seconded to approve the Treasurer’s Report for September.  The motion passed.

 Insurance Funding

 McDonald recounted problems related to premium payments during the ownership change for the Association’s building insurance and proposed a solution.  Following discussion, McDonald moved and Boulware seconded that the Board transfer $40,000 from the Capital Improvement account to the Operating account for payment to Liberty Mutual, leaving a balance of $9,112.20 payable over the following three months. The motion passed.

 Aged Receivables

 Glamba expressed concerns over the large amount in the aged receivables.  Following discussion, the Board agreed to request Willow Properties to prepare and send letters to all members who are delinquent by more than $1,000 reminding them of their obligation for payment of assessments.

 Reserve Study

 Glamba reported Associatrion Reserves will be setting up a Reserve Study visit with Oakbrook Townhouses this week.

 Water Leak at 7811 Zircon

 Glamba reported work on this issue is awaiting approval of an emergency permit from the City of Lakewood.

 Status of Ruby/Zircon Development

 Glamba reported that seven of the sixteen permitted properties have apparently not been sold to date and that construction work is continuing on others.

 Status of Chambers Creek Trail and Encampments

 Glamba reported on a trek thru most of the Chambers Creek canyon by Karch and himself, including securing of GPS coordinates and photos. Karch reported they found two encampments on the south side of the canyon, east of Oakbrook Townhouses property, but they were unable to continue to the west end of the property due to blow-down and the swampy nature of the canyon. Karch reported the most recent (October, 2022) promotional videos of the proposed trail system continue to show the entire trail to be on the north side of Chambers Creek, with a second footbridge to be constructed across the Creek in 2023 about a quarter mile west of the Zircon Drive trailhead (which is approximately across from the Oakbrook Golf Club building).  Other access points include Kobayashi Park in University Place and a trailhead at the end of Phillips Road on the south side of the creek.

 Pierce County has been notified of the reported encampment just west of Oakbrook Townhouses property.  Glamba reported he signed the interagency agreement with the City of Lakewood Police Department (LPD) on trespassing, authorizing the LPD to act as the association’s agent in enforcing both vehicle and foot trespassing on Association property, and is securing needed signs to that effect to be posted on Association property.

 Deadwooding of Honey Locust Tree at 7611 Zircon and Plum Tree Pruning at 7613 Zircon

 Glamba reported both projects are complete.

 Fines Policy

 Glamba reported that comments had been received from our attorney on the draft fines policy, which has been amended to reflect those comments, and recommended adoption and transmittal to the membership, along with an introduction previously prepared.  Following discussion, Boulware moved and Karch seconded that the Board approve the fines policy and transmit it to the membership along with the introduction, on a different color paper. The motion passed.

 No Trespassing Signs

 Glamba reported on his efforts to secure no trespassing signs in accordance with the LPD interagency agreement, including preparation of the signs, securing necessary posts for the signs, and securing utility locates prior to installation.  Board members suggested our maintenance contractor be authorized to secure the posts and install the signs once utility locates have been completed.

 Application of Herbicides

 Glamba reported on lawsuits related to a Monsanto herbicide product, Roundup.  Karch reported on his experiences regulating insecticides, fungicides, and rodenticides in the Midwest, and urged the Board not to approve, or to use, any such items on the Association’s common area without ensuring that any such use be by an approved, licensed applicator. Boulware suggested the Board adopt a policy requiring Board approval of any chemical application in the common area, so that, in the event of such use without approval, the responsibility for any damages would rest with the member doing such application. Discussion revealed the need to consider this issue further and the discussion was deferred to a future meeting.

 Protection of Sprinkler Heads

 The Board considered options for protecting sprinkler heads from driving or parking off the driveways by members, their guests, or contractors, which results in considerable costs to the Association for repairs. Further discussion was deferred to a future meeting.

 Update on Heritage Restoration Lawsuit

 Glamba reported on the request for production of documents filed with the court by our attorney.

 Update on Painting Request at 7631 Zircon

 Glamba reported that the request was approved by electronic vote of the Board for repainting a portion of the sunroom walls at 7631 Zircon resulting from roofing repair work.

 Ensuring Timely Payment of Insurance Premiums

 Glamba reported on our management company’s apparent failure to pay certain insurance premiums in a timely manner, resulting in a notice of cancellation.  Actions taken by the association and its insurance broker in the past month have reinstated all insurance, without a break in coverage.

 Willow Properties Management Agreement

 Glamba reported on his review of the proposed management agreement with Willow Properties.  Board members contributed many comments, and agreed on the need to secure a copy of the agreement with Northwest Properties for evaluation and comparison. Boulware moved and Karch seconded to authorize the President to secure a copy of the NWP contract. The motion passed.

 2023 Budget

 McDonald offered the first reading of a proposed 2023 budget for Oakbrook Townhouses.  He recommended minor adjustments among line items, and created a balanced budget without the need for an increase in monthly charges. A second reading will occur in November, with final passage scheduled for December, to meet the 30 day requirement to send to the membership prior to the Annual Members’ Meeting in January.

 Next Board Meeting

 The next Board meeting is tentatively scheduled for Monday, November 14, 2022 at 7:00 PM, at 7705 Zircon Drive.

 Adjournment

 It was moved and seconded to adjourn the meeting. The motion passed.  The meeting was adjourned at 8:44 PM.

 Respectfully submitted,

  

 

Al Glamba, President